San Juan is more than just sandy beaches and vibrant nightlife—it’s also a paradise for pizza lovers. From the charming streets of Old San Juan to the trendy vibes of Condado and Santurce, the city offers a range of pizzerias that are sure to delight your taste buds. Here’s your ultimate guide to the best pizza in San Juan
1. Pirilo Pizza Rústica – A Rustic Favorite in Old San Juan
Located in the heart of historic Old San Juan, Pirilo Pizza Rústica is a must-visit for its cozy ambiance and rustic charm. The restaurant is housed in a beautifully restored colonial building, with wooden beams and brick walls that transport you to another time.
The menu features a wide variety of pizzas, but their signature Pirilo Pizza stands out. It’s topped with local ingredients like Sweet Plantains, Ground Beef, and Fresh Mozzarella, creating a perfect fusion of Puerto Rican and Italian flavors. Pair your pizza with one of their craft beers or a glass of sangria for the ultimate dining experience. Whether you’re dining in or taking your pizza to go, Pirilo never disappoints.
Location: 207 Calle de la Tanca, Old San Juan
2. La Santurcina – Santurce’s Trendy Pizza Spot
In the lively Santurce neighborhood, La Santurcina has become a favorite among foodies. Known for its trendy decor and laid-back atmosphere, this pizzeria specializes in wood-fired pizzas that are cooked to perfection.
One of the highlights is their La Del Chef Pizza, featuring Tomato, Pancetta, Caramalized Onions, Pecorino, Mozzarella, Chili Flakes. The crispy, charred crust adds an extra layer of flavor that keeps patrons coming back for more. Beyond pizza, La Santurcina also offers a great selection of craft beers and cocktails, making it an ideal spot for a night out with friends.
Location: 1250 Ponce de León Ave, Santurce, San Juan
3. Di Zucchero – Gourmet Pizzas in Condado
For an upscale pizza experience, Di Zucchero in Condado is the place to be. This chic pizzeria offers a modern setting with stylish decor and a lively atmosphere. Perfect for both casual dinners and special occasions, Di Zucchero serves gourmet pizzas that are as beautiful as they are delicious.
The John Gotti Pizza is a standout, topped with Argentinean Sausage, Sweet Hamm Prosciutto, Olive Oil, Asparagus and the Chef’s Special Mushroom Sauce. It’s indulgent, rich, and pairs perfectly with a glass of wine from their extensive list. The restaurant also offers a variety of pastas and appetizers, making it a great choice for a full Italian-inspired meal.
Location: 1210 Ashford Ave, Condado, San Juan
4. Bari Handcrafted Pizza – A Hidden Gem in Old San Juan
Tucked away in the charming streets of Old San Juan, Bari Handcrafted Pizza is a cozy pizzeria that specializes in Neapolitan-style pizzas. The wood-fired oven gives their pizzas a perfectly charred crust that’s crisp on the outside and soft on the inside.
Their Margherita Pizza is a classic favorite, topped with San Marzano Tomatoes, Fresh Mozzarella, and fragrant Basil. Each bite is a testament to the quality and simplicity of their ingredients. The intimate setting and friendly service make Bari a delightful spot to unwind after exploring the historic district.
Location: 154 Calle del Cristo, Old San Juan
5. Muzzarella – A Local Favorite on Avenida Central
Located on Avenida Central, Muzzarella is a family-friendly pizzeria known for its generous portions and comforting flavors. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, making it a great spot for casual dinners with family or friends.
The Four Cheese Pizza is a must-try, featuring a blend of Brie, Mozzarella, Munster and Parmesan. The combination of creamy and sharp cheeses creates a flavor explosion with every bite. Muzzarella also offers a variety of appetizers, pastas, and desserts, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
Location: 165 Av. Central, San Juan
Exploring San Juan’s Pizza Scene
From historic Old San Juan to the bustling streets of Santurce and Condado, San Juan’s pizza scene has something for every palate. Whether you’re looking for traditional wood-fired pies, gourmet creations, or inventive Puerto Rican-inspired toppings, these pizzerias deliver on flavor, atmosphere, and quality.
San Juan is a haven for pizza lovers, offering a diverse range of pizzerias that cater to every craving. Whether you’re enjoying the rustic vibes of Pirilo Pizza Rústica, indulging in the gourmet creations at Di Zucchero, or savoring the family-friendly comfort of Muzzarella, each spot promises an unforgettable slice of Puerto Rico. So, grab a table, order your favorite pizza, and discover why San Juan’s pizza scene is truly one of a kind.
Photos by La Santurcina, Di Zucchero and Bari Handcrafted Pizza
